Tagged: shortstop

Missing #4- Kid Elberfeld

You can dedicate your life to baseball and have a dramatic impact on people and the game. However, this does not mean you are destined for Cooperstown. Norman Arthur Elberfeld grew up in Cincinnati, cheering for the Reds and made a name for himself on local diamonds. The Tabasco Kid, or Kid, played primarily Shortstop for 14 seasons with six teams: Philadelphia Phillies (1898), Cincinnati Reds (1899), Detroit Tigers (1901-1903), New York Highlanders (1903-1909), Washington Nationals (1910-1911), and Brooklyn Dodgers (1914). He spent the 1908 season as the Player-Manager for the New York Highlanders, guiding them to a 27-71 record, .276 WL%. Elberfeld was a much better Major League player than manager. 

Elberfeld appeared on the 1936 Hall of Fame ballot. This came after a career in which he played in 1,292 Games, scored 647 Runs, collected 1,235 Hits, including 169 Doubles, 56 Triples, 10 Home Runs, 535 RBI, 213 Stolen Bases, drew 427 Walks, 166 Strikeouts, posted a .271 BA, .355 OBP, .339 SLG, .694 OPS, and 106 OPS+. Elberfeld turned Hit By the Pitch into an art form. His 165 Hit By Pitches still ranks 19th all time. 

Defensively, Elberfeld played in 1,265 Games, made 1,196 Starts, 1,135 Complete Games, 10,835 Innings, had 6,993 Chances, made 2,681 Putouts, with 3,774 Assists, committed 538 Errors, .923 FLD%, 5.36 RF/9, and 5.10 RF/G. He was fearless, never shying away from confrontation. Elberfeld wore a whalebone shin guard after being spiked multiple times while turning Double Plays. His aggression towards opposing players and umpires, leading to multiple injuries, fights, and suspensions. 

Kid Elberfeld was ruthless in his pursuit of winning. (George Grantham Bain Collection- Library of Congress)

The best season of Elberfeld’s career came with the 1901 Detroit Tigers. He played in 121 Games, scored 76 Runs, collected 133 Hits, including 21 Doubles, 11 Triples, 3 Home Runs, 76 RBI, 23 Stolen Bases, drew 57 Walks, 18 Strikeouts, with a .308 BA, .397 OBP, .428 SLG, .825 OPS, and 125 OPS+. Elberfeld posted career bests in Triples, Home Runs, RBI, BA, SLG, and OPS. Despite the great start, Elberfeld failed to build a Hall of Fame career. 

The game continues to change so it is only appropriate to compare Elberfeld to his contemporaries who were elected to Cooperstown. There are 26 Hall of Fame Shortstops, of which six played during the Dead Ball Era. The average Dead Ball Era Shortstop played 19 seasons, 2,078 career Games, scored 1,253 Runs, collected 2,286 Hits, including 369 Doubles, 143 Triples, 47 Home Runs, 1,131 RBI, 463 Stolen Bases, drew 633 Walks, 499 Strikeouts, with a .290 BA, .350 OBP, .388 SLG, .738 OPS, 113 OPS+, and 69.4 WAR. These Shortstops played their way into the Hall of Fame. Kid Elberfeld did not. He was only better by having 333 fewer Strikeouts and a .005 higher OBP. It is not a close comparison.  

Kid Elberfeld was a true baseball man, spending time as a coach, scout, mentor, and teacher. He was good for the game, but not a Hall of Famer. On the 1936 ballot, Elberfeld received 1 vote, 0.4%. He was tied for the 39th most votes on the ballot. He would appear on the Hall of Fame ballot five times, peaking with 0.8% in both 1938 and 1945. The Hall of Fame voters got it right. Kid Elberfeld does not deserve to be enshrined in Cooperstown. Sometimes the value of an honor is shown through those not receiving it. 

DJ

2023 Hall of Fame Ballot

The 2023 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot is filled with talented players who spent at least a decade playing on a Major League diamond. The election results will be announced tomorrow, January 24th. As is tradition, The Winning Run has filled out its own officially unofficial ballot. We have been writing about baseball for more than a decade, but we lack the credentials to be full voting members of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America (BBWAA). No matter, we humbly submit our ballot anyway.

There are 28 candidates on the 2023 Hall of Fame ballot. Each hopes to join Fred McGriff, who was elected in December through the Contemporary Era Committee, in Cooperstown. There are 14 returning candidates and 14 first year candidates on the ballot. The 2023 ballot is also the final year of eligibility for Jeff Kent. If he is not elected this year, his path into the Hall of Fame will be through the committees. 

The BBWAA is the sole voting body for the National Baseball Hall of Fame. As such, only members of the BBWAA who meet the following eligibility requirements can vote.

Voter Eligibility 

  1. Any member of the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA) who has been an active member for ten years.
  2. The BBWAA is limited to writers for newspapers only, including some internet newspapers. 

The BBWAA sets the rules for how eligible voters can vote.

Voting Rules

  1. Vote for no more than 10 players.
  2. A player is eligible for election to the Baseball Hall of Fame if they meet the following criteria:
    1. They competed in ten seasons. A single game counts as a season played.
    2. The player has been retired for at least five seasons. The clock restarts if the player returns and plays in the Major Leagues.
    3. The player is not on the ineligible list; banned from baseball. 
  3. The player must receive 5% of the vote to remain on the ballot.
  4. The player is elected if they receive at least 75% of all ballots cast. 

In addition to the official voting rules for the Baseball Hall of Fame set forth by the BBWAA, The Winning Run has its own rule for its ballot. 

The Winning Run Rules

  1. Known PED users are ineligible.

Every player dreams of reaching the Major Leagues and playing at such a level that their ultimate destination is Cooperstown. However, this dream is a reality for only 1% of those who reach the Major Leagues. Thousands of players begin their careers dreaming of the Hall of Fame and never spend a single day on a Major League roster. The difficulty of reaching the Major Leagues makes simply appearing on the Hall of Fame ballot, even for a single year, an accomplishment reserved for baseball’s elites. Making the ballot is an honor, even if the candidate does not receive a single vote.

The honor of appearing on the 2023 Hall of Fame ballot belongs to these 28 candidates, their year of eligibility, and percentage of the Hall of Fame vote received in 2022. 

  1. Scott Rolen- 6th (63.2%)
  2. Todd Helton- 5th (52.0%)
  3. Billy Wagner- 8th (51.0%)
  4. Andruw Jones- 6th (41.4%)
  5. Gary Sheffield- 9th (40.6%)
  6. Alex Rodriguez- 2nd (34.3%)
  7. Jeff Kent- 10th (32.7%)
  8. Manny Ramirez- 7th (28.9%)
  9. Omar Vizquel- 6th (23.9%)
  10. Andy Pettitte- 5th (10.7%)
  11. Jimmy Rollins- 2nd (9.4%)
  12. Bobby Abreu- 4th (8.6%)
  13. Mark Buehrle- 3rd (5.8%)
  14. Torii Hunter- 3rd (5.3%)
  15. Carlos Beltran- 1st
  16. John Lackey- 1st
  17. Jered Weaver- 1st
  18. Jacoby Ellsbury- 1st
  19. Matt Cain- 1st
  20. Jhonny Peralta- 1st
  21. Jayson Werth- 1st
  22. J.J. Hardy- 1st
  23. Mike Napoli- 1st
  24. Bronson Arroyo- 1st
  25. R.A. Dickey- 1st
  26. Francisco Rodriguez- 1st
  27. Andre Ethier- 1st
  28. Huston Street- 1st

Following our own rule, 5 of the 28 candidates were removed from consideration due to their connections with PEDs. 

  1. Gary Sheffield
  2. Alex Rodriguez
  3. Manny Ramirez
  4. Andy Pettitte
  5. Jhonny Peralta

This left 23 candidates on our ballot, from which we could vote for a maximum of 10. The choices are never easy. Previous ballots we have unofficially voted on have contained more than 10 Hall of Fame caliber candidates. Reviewing our ballot from 2022 helped in beginning the voting process. Were the 10 players we voted for last year still the best choices? The Winning Run’s ballot last year listed these 10 candidates: 

  1. Bobby Abreu (8.6%)
  2. Mark Buehrle (5.8%)
  3. Todd Helton (52.0%)
  4. Tim Hudson (3.0%)
  5. Torii Hunter (5.3%)
  6. Andruw Jones (41.4%)
  7. Jeff Kent (32.7%)
  8. Tim Lincecum (2.3%)
  9. Scott Rolen (63.2%)
  10. Billy Wagner (51.0%)

Based upon the voting, none of our candidates were elected to Cooperstown. Two of our votes are open again as Tim Hudson and Tim Lincecum failed to receive the minimum 5% of votes. This left us with eight returning candidates on this year’s ballot. This is our unofficially official 2023 ballot.  

We removed Torii Hunter from our ballot and replaced him with Jimmy Rollins. Hunter was our final choice on last year’s ballot. Rollins was on the ballot in 2022, but after reexamining every candidate, we concluded that Rollins was the more deserving candidate. Hall of Fame voting is not a perfect process, which we have previously examined. The process too is foiled because the voters themselves are imperfect. Reaching rational decisions is not easy when more than 300 voters must agree for a candidate to reach Cooperstown. Francisco Rodriguez and Carlos Beltran took our two open votes. Both are deserving first year candidates. Torii Hunter and Omar Vizquel were the top candidates not receiving our vote. None of these men are flawless, but their off the field actions have no impact on our voting. Yes the character clause exists, but they who are without fault shall cast the first stone. The Winning Run used all 10 of our votes, but we wanted 12.

Who will join Fred McGriff in Cooperstown this summer? (Stephen Dunn/ Getty Images)

Francisco Rodriguez pitched for five teams during his 16 season career: Anaheim/ Los Angeles of Anaheim Angels (2002-2008), New York Mets (2009-2011), Milwaukee Brewers (2011-2013, 2014-2015), Baltimore Orioles (2013), and Detroit Tigers (2016-2017). Rodriguez pitched in 948 Games, Finished 677 Games, converted 437 Saves, Pitcher 976 Innings, posted a 52-53 record, 1,142 Strikeouts, 389 Walks, with a 2.86 ERA, 1.155 WHIP, and 148 ERA+. He won the 2002 World Series with the Angels. He was a six time All Star and twice the American League Rolaids Relief Award winner. Rodriguez finished in the top four of Cy Young Award voting three times. He led baseball in Saves three times and Saved 40 Games six times. Rodriguez’s 437 career Saves are the fourth most all time, behind Hall of Famers Mariano Rivera, Trevor Hoffman, and Lee Smith

Jimmy Rollins helped to set the standard for modern Shortstops. He played for three teams during his 17 season career: Philadelphia Phillies (2000-2014), Los Angeles Dodgers (2015), and Chicago White Sox (2016). Rollins played in 2,275 Games, collected 2,455 Hits, 511 Doubles, 115 Triples, 231 Home Runs, 936 RBI, 1,421 Runs scored, 470 Stolen Bases, 813 Walks, 1,264 Strikeouts, posted a .264 BA, .324 OBP, .418 SLG, .743 OPS, and 95 OPS+. Rollins led the National League in Triples four times. He stole 30 Bases ten times. Rollins was a three time All Star, won four Gold Gloves, a Silver Slugger, and the 2007 National League MVP. Defensively, Rollins played 2,227 Games at Shortstop, totally 19,513.2 Innings, had 9,275 Chances, made 2,982 Putouts, 6,139 Assists, committed 154 Errors, turned 1,249 Double Plays, and posted a .983 Fielding %. Rollins played the sixth most Games at Shortstop, the most not in the Hall of Fame. He is 20th in Assists and 12th in Double Plays. He was one of the leaders for the Phillies in their 2008 World Series victory. 

Carlos Beltran went from young phenom to wise veteran. He played for seven teams during his 20 season career: Kansas City Royals (1998-2004), Houston Astros (2004, 2017), New York Mets (2005-2011), San Francisco Giants (2011), St. Louis Cardinals (2012-2013), New York Yankees (2014-2016), and Texas Rangers (2016). Primarily patrolling Centerfield, Beltran played in 2,586 Games, collected 2,725 Hits, 565 Doubles, 78 Triples, 435 Home Runs, 1,587 RBI, 1,582 Runs scored, 312 Stolen Bases, 1,084 Walks, 1,795 Strikeouts, posted a .279 BA, .350 OBP, .486 SLG, .837 OPS, 119 OPS+. Defensively, he had above average Range for two decades. He won the 1999 American League Rookie of the Year. Beltran was a nine time All Star, won three Gold Gloves, and two Silver Sluggers. He helped five different teams reach the Postseason and provided the veteran leadership, not always within the rules, the Astros needed to win the 2017 World Series. 

Removing Torii Hunter from our ballot was not fun. He was our final selection last year, but his career still deserves recognition. Additionally, Omar Vizquel once again comes up short because of his lack of offense. 

We will find out tomorrow if anyone will join Fred McGriff in Cooperstown. There are many deserving candidates, but we must wait to see if 75% of the writers can agree. 

DJ

United States of Baseball- North Carolina

The Tar Heel State has a proud sports history. While the Duke and North Carolina rivalry is among the best in American sports, the state does not lack in baseball. North Carolina has sent 476 players to the Major Leagues. The greatest pitcher born in the Tar Heel State is Gaylord Perry. His 93.02 career WAR is the 10th highest among state and territory pitching leaders. The best position player from North Carolina is Luke Appling. His 77.11 career WAR is 22nd among position player leaders. The Tar Heel State has a combined 170.13 WAR, ranking North Carolina 15th in the United States of Baseball. 

A little vaseline, spit, or grease ought to do the trick. Gaylord Perry made a career out of throwing the Spitball, or so he was accused. The Right Hander pitched for 22 seasons with 8 teams: San Francisco Giants (1962-1971), Cleveland Indians (1972-1975), Texas Rangers (1975-1977, 1980), San Diego Padres (1978-1979), New York Yankees (1980), Atlanta Braves (1981), Seattle Mariners (1982-1983), and Kansas City Royals (1983). He was constantly tugging, touching, rubbing, wiping, and pulling on his uniform, hat, and hair which enraged opposing batters and managers. They assumed he was throwing a Spitball, which had been outlawed by MLB in 1920. The Williamston native was much more than a cheat, he was among the great pitchers of his era. Perry’s brother Jim, who enjoyed his own long Major League career, was a Minor League pitcher with the Cleveland Indians when the San Francisco Giants signed Gaylord for 3 years and $60,000 out of high school. Both Perry brothers found success and in 1970 they became the first brothers to each win 20 games in the same season. 

Gaylord Perry pitched in 777 career Games, made 690 Starts, threw 303 Complete Games, including 53 Shutouts, 5,350 Innings Pitched, allowed 4,938 Hits, 2,128 Runs, 1,846 Earned Runs, 399 Home Runs, 1,379 Walks, 3,534 Strikeouts, posted a 314-265 record, 3.11 ERA, 1.181 WHIP, and 117 ERA+. He remains fifth in Hits allowed, sixth in Losses, seventh in Batters Faced, eighth in Strikeouts, ninth in Starts, 14th in Home Runs, 16th in Shutouts, and 17th in Wins. He was a five time All Star. He twice won the Cy Young Award, winning the 1972 American League Cy Young with the Indians and the 1978 National League Cy Young with the Padres at 39 years old. Perry was the first pitcher to win the award in both leagues. 

So much of Gaylord Perry’s career is shrouded in secrecy that it is hard to separate truth from fiction. He claims the first Spitball he threw in a Major League game was in May 1964. There are managers and batters who suggest otherwise. Perry developed a routine to load up the baseball after 1967 when pitchers could no longer blow on or lick their fingers without wiping them off. He spent the offseason rehearsing in front of a mirror so his routine was ready for Spring Training. Despite the theatrics, Perry pitched well, maybe too well. The Cardinals thought so on September 17, 1968. They complained loudly as Perry threw a No Hitter against St. Louis and Bob Gibson, winning 1-0. The Redbirds had little room to complain the next day when Ray Washburn also threw another No Hitter. This was the first time a team was No Hit on back to back days in the same series. 

Perry was not skilled with a bat in his hands, prompting Giants manager Alvin Dark to say, “Mark my words a man will land on the moon before Gaylord Perry hits a Home Run.” Dark was right. Perry did not hit his first Home Run until 30 minutes after Neil Armstrong set foot on the moon. 

Gaylord Perry’s time in San Diego was brief but he left a lacking impact on the Padres. (National Baseball Hall of Fame)

After the 1971 season, the Giants broke up their aging team. Willie Mays, Willie McCovey, and Juan Marichal were all traded, as was Perry who landed in Cleveland. Despite clashing with manager Frank Robinson, Perry was terrific next to Lake Erie, winning his first Cy Young Award. In 1974, after losing his first Start, he won his next 15 decisions. All 15 victories were Complete Games. His record stood at 15-1 with a 1.31 ERA at the All Star Break. Despite his brilliance, Perry was unhappy and was traded to Billy Martin and the Texas Rangers in 1975. 

Perry’s career as an elite journey man had begun. He was again traded in 1978, this time to the San Diego Padres. The Rangers needed cash and the Padres needed a veteran. He responded by winning his second Cy Young and becoming the third pitcher to win 20 games with three different teams, joining Carl Mays and Pete Alexander. Rangers owner Brad Corbett publicly regretted trading Perry and said a front office job was waiting for him when he retired. San Diego rightly levied tampering charges against the Rangers. Once again, success meant little as Perry was traded back to Texas in 1980 after feuding with Padres management. The reunion did not last. He was again on the move, traded to the Yankees in June. He found some success in the Bronx, but was left off the Postseason roster. 

Finally in control of his own future as a free agent, Perry signed with the Atlanta Braves in 1981. He was closing in on 300 wins. However, the Player’s Strike cost him several Starts and he finished the season with 297 wins. Perry was a free agent sitting just three wins away from 300. The phone sat silent for much of the Winter until the Seattle Mariners finally called. The elusive 300th victory came on May 6, 1982 against the Yankees. Perry threw a Complete Game, winning 7-3. He was the first 300 game winner since Early Wynn in 1963. 

Perry was finally caught throwing a Spitball on August 23, 1982. Two suspect pitches and Home Plate umpire Dave Phillips tossed him for doctoring the ball. Seattle released Perry in the middle of the summer and his final stop was Kansas City. His greatest contribution to the Royals was during the infamous Pine Tar Game. On August 18, 1983, Billy Martin and the Yankees protested George Brett’s Home Run, saying the pine tar was too far up the bat. The umpires agreed and called Brett out, who promptly went crazy. In the chaos, Perry grabbed the bat and ran for the clubhouse. Security and the umpires gave chase, caught him, and ejected him. Gaylord Perry’s long and colorful career came to an end after the 1983 season. He retired with the third most Strikeouts and 11th most Wins at the time. Perry was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1991. 

The best season of Perry’s career was with the 1972 Cleveland Indians. He pitched in 41 Games, made 40 Starts, threw 29 Complete Games, including 5 Shutouts, 342.2 Innings Pitched, allowed 253 Hits, 79 Runs, 73 Earned Runs, 17 Home Runs, 82 Walks, 234 Strikeouts, posted a 24-16 record, 1.92 ERA, 0.978 WHIP, and 168 ERA+. He led the American League in Wins and Complete Games. Perry set career bests in Wins, ERA, WHIP, and ERA+, while equalling his best in Complete Games. In his 29 Complete Games, he pitched into Extra Innings eight times. Perry’s efforts earned him his third All Star selection, finished sixth for the MVP, and won the Cy Young Award. Cleveland however finished fifth, well out of the Postseason. 

Despite having a Hall of Fame career, Perry pitched for many bad teams. He appeared in the Postseason once, the 1971 National League Championship Series with Giants. Perry pitched in 2 Games, made 2 Strats, threw 1 Complete Game, 14.2 Innings Pitched, allowed 19 Hits, 11 Runs, 10 Earned Runs, 1 Home Run, 3 Walks, 11 Strikeouts, posted a 1-1 record, 6.14 ERA, and 1.500 WHIP. He allowed 3 Earned Runs in a 5-4 Complete Game victory in Game 1. Perry lost the Pennant clinching Game 4, giving up 7 Runs to the Pirates in 5 ⅔ Innings.  

Old Aches and Pains would complain about every little thing, as hypochondriacs do, and then go get three hits. Luke Appling was the Shortstop on the South Side of Chicago for two decades. The High Point native signed with the Atlanta Crackers of the Southern Association out of Oglethorpe College. In 1930, the Cubs bought the Crackers and sold Appling across town for $20,000. He played 20 seasons with the Chicago White Sox (1930-1943, 1945-1950), missing 1944 and nearly all of 1945 serving in the military. He was a great hitter, but his defense was lacking at the start of his career. After a tough first season Appling stopped swinging for the fences, which changed the trajectory of his career. He played in 2,422 career Games, collected 2,749 Hits, 440 Doubles, 102 Triples, 45 Home Runs, 1,116 RBI, scored 1,319 Runs, 179 Stolen Bases, 1,302 Walks, 528 Strikeouts, .310 BA, .399 OBP, .398 SLG, .798 OPS, and 113 OPS+. Appling was a seven time All Star. He won two Batting Titles, 1936 and 1943, and twice finished second for the American League MVP.

After early struggles, Appling became a solid defensive Shortstop, amassing 19.1 career dWAR. He led the Junior Circuit in Assists seven times, Errors five times, and Double Plays three times. Appling remains fifth in Double Plays by a Shortstop, sixth in Assists, seventh in Putouts, eighth in Assists and Games Played, and 12th in Errors. An incredible transformation for a player the White Sox tried to trade after the 1930 season, but found no interest. 

Many legendary players have worn a White Sox uniform, but none earned more WAR on the South Side of Chicago than Appling. He is the White Sox leader in Games Played, Runs, Hits, Doubles, RBI, Walks, At Bats, and Total Bases. He is also third in Triples. When he retired, Appling held the American League record for Assists, Putouts, and Chances by a Shortstop, and the Major League record for Games Played by a Shortstop. He was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1964. 

Luke Appling was a great hitter on some very bad White Sox teams. (National Baseball Hall of Fame)

Luke Appling was a baseball lifer. He managed the Memphis Chicks beginning in 1951. Appling was so successful, he won the Minor League Manager of the Year award in 1952. He also managed Indianapolis and Richmond before returning to the Majors coaching the Tigers, Indians, Orioles, Athletics, and Braves. His only Major League managing was the final 40 games of the 1967 season after the Kansas City Athletics fired Alvin Dark. The A’s went 10-30 under Appling. In 1982, during an Old Timer All Star game, the 75 years old Appling launched an improbable Home Run off Warren Spahn. Make that 46 career Home Runs.  

The best season of Appling’s career was 1936. He played in 138 Games, collected 204 Hits, 31 Doubles, 7 Triples, 6 Home Runs, 128 RBI, scored 111 Runs, 10 Stolen Bases, 85 Walks, 25 Strikeouts, .388 BA, .474 OBP, .508 SLG, .981 OPS, and 139 OPS+. He won the Batting Title with the highest single season BA for a Shortstop in the 20th century. Appling had career highs in Runs score, Hits, RBI, BA, OBP, SLG, and OPS. He also put together a 27 game hitting streak. Appling was an All Star and finished second in a close race for the American League MVP behind Lou Gehrig

Appling, like fellow Chicago legend Ernie Banks, never played in the Postseason. The White Sox were dreadful, having just four winning seasons with Appling. In three of those seasons there was no real hope of reaching the World Series. The White Sox finished Fourth and 20 Games Back in 1936, they finished Third in 1937 and 1939, but 16 and 22.5 Games Back respectively. The closest Appling ever came was 1940. Chicago finished only 8 Games Back of the Pennant winning Detroit Tigers. However, they tied for fourth in a very tight American League. 

North Carolina is home to 11 Minor League and two independent league teams. The availability of professional baseball in the Tar Heel State is among the highest anywhere. There are seven North Carolinians in the Hall of Fame: Luke Appling, Rick Ferrell, Catfish Hunter, Buck Leonard, Gaylord Perry, Enos Slaughter, and Hoyt Wilheim. There will surely be more. Next week the United States of Baseball heads to the Great Plains and The Peace Garden State. North Dakota is next. 

DJ

The King of the Golden Age

Let’s start with the obvious. Fernando Tatis Jr. is a generational talent with the bat in his hands. He can do it all, which is why the Padres rewarded him with a gigantic contract. There is no debating his talent, but Tatis needs to improve his defense.

The 22 year old Shortstop has work to do in the field. In 164 career Games, Tatis has played 1,414.2 Innings, had 606 Chances, made 194 Putouts, with 380 Assists, 32 Errors, turned 79 Double Plays, posting a .947 FLD%, 3.65 RF/9, 3.50 RF/G, and -21 Rtot. His FLD% is -.023 below league average. This is not always an indicator of a poor fielder. However a low FLD% combined with below average range is not great. Tatis is -0.17 RF/9 and -0.23 RF/G below league average. His defense allows opponents to score 20 more runs a season than if he were replaced by a league average defender. He is reaching 35 fewer balls in play, making 47 fewer plays, and committing 18 more errors. This hurts the Padres in a tough division against the Dodgers where every game is critical. 

Fernando Tatis Jr. is already a super star despite playing below average defense. (Orlando Ramirez/ Associated Press)

Yes this critique of Tatis is nitpicking. However, he is the face of the Shortstop Golden Age. Tatis with Javier Baez, Carlos Correa, and Francisco Lindor should rule baseball for the next decade. This Mount Rushmore of modern Shortstops does not include Andrelton Simmons as he is already an all time great defender. It also lacks Trea Turner, Trevor Story, and Corey Seager who are also elite. Baez is an above average Shortstop, who creates plenty of highlights. His Range is slightly better than league average, but his FLD% is below average. Correa is a very good defensive Shortstop, saving the Astros 33 runs in his career defensively. Lindor is an elite Shortstop with 59 career defensive runs saved. Collectively, they are redefining what an elite Shortstop is. Tatis does not need to be the second coming of Ozzie Smith or Andrelton Simmons. If he becomes league average his value only increases and he makes San Diego better. 

Tatis is not moving off Shortstop. He played 154 Innings between Second and Third in the Minors. He is the Padres Shortstop now and in the future. His infectious energy makes baseball better. Maybe it does not matter if Tatis’ defense improves. Maybe we should just enjoy watching him play every night, but imagine how special Tatis can be if he becomes an all around player.

The Golden Age of the Shortstop is here. The era of Derek Jeter, Alex Rodriguez, and Nomar Garciaparra was once the peak. It included two Hall of Fame talents and a third that seemed destined for Cooperstown. This current group of Shortstops may have even more talent and are laying the foundation for their induction into the Hall of Fame. Enjoy this special era in baseball while it lasts.

DJ

Stepping Back In Time

I walked around the field where I played most of my organized baseball a few weeks ago. It was a cold December day. The grass was dead, everything was still. I remember playing baseball.

Putting on the catchers gear and awkwardly trotting to home plate. Chasing a Wild Pitch to the backstop and firing to Second Base in an attempt to catch the base stealer. Fielding the ball at Shortstop and throwing across the diamond. Lunging for a throw at Third Base while trying to keep my foot on the bag, which was counterproductive. Chasing a base hit in Right-Center that rolled into a drainage pipe. Throwing my hands up to say the ball was gone forever. Standing inside the chain link dugouts, which have shrunk with time. The smell of Gatorade and leather. Feeling the bat hit the ball. Sprinting to First while the helmet’s face cage rattled, just beating the throw. Effortlessly driving the ball down the Right Field line. Racing around the bases before unnecessarily sliding home to complete an Inside-The-Park Home Run. The mound, which felt like standing on top of a mountain, is gone. I threw one competitive pitch in my life, a fly out to Center. The sound and feel of my cleats on the dirt. The sting of catching the ball in the palm of my glove. Melting in the summer heat. Adding layer after layer during Fall Ball.

Playing baseball here felt like the World Series every time. (The Winning Run/DJ)

Most of my memories as a player are of having fun. I stopped playing in the sixth grade because I was not very good and the coaches took away the joy. I could have played for another year or two, but I walked away sooner due to the toxic environment. I choose to focus on the positive of my playing time. Stepping on the field again caused the memories to come flooding back. I remember the joy of baseball. We should all try to focus on the joys in life, not the negative.

DJ

I’m Fascinated by Sacrifice Flies

Tim Kurkjian’s love of baseball is obvious to everyone who listens or reads his work. He was born to report and write about baseball. His love of the game oozes off the pages of his book, I’m Fascinated by Sacrifice Flies: Inside The Game We All Love. It is everything you want and expect from a reflective book written by someone who has spent much of their life covering baseball.

I’m Fascinated by Sacrifice Flies reads like a memoir. However, the focus is not on Kurkjian, rather on the world of baseball he has spent decades covering. The grand moments are obvious, but the smaller, more intimate moments create the memories. Admittedly a reader needs some baseball background to fully appreciate the stories. Tales about baseball lifer Don Zimmer are best when he is remembered as a tough manager and the grandfather of baseball. Knowing this background information helps connect the organized stream of consciousness in the book. 

The chapters are poignant and personal. Kurkjian’s two decades long obsession with box scores before suddenly stopping cold turkey is both heartwarming and breaking.  The obituaries for his friends Tony Gwynn, Don Zimmer, Earl Weaver, and Mike Flanagan are the remembrances of baseball lives well lived. Life and baseball are built on personal relationships. Baseball players are human with lives on AND off the diamond. Kurkjian understands this and his friendships with these men show the humanity within the game. There is plenty of crying in baseball, both happy and sad.

Tim Kurkjian was born for baseball. (St. Martin’s Press)

Quirkjians are one of Tim Kurkjian’s greatest contributions to baseball. He is not the first person to love mundane baseball trivia. However, his love for these tidbits is contagious. Few care about a small event happening for the first time in 100 years, or ever, but Kurkjian has the ability to entice the audience to care. His fascination with the minute only gives weight to his discussions on more important events. Quirkjians are not consumed in large quantities. They are to be studied, bounced around in your mind as you read or watch along. Quirkjians are the appetizers of baseball. Too many and they spoil the main course, they should wet your appetite for what is to come.

I’m Fascinated by Sacrifice Flies is an easy read with an ample supply of anecdotes about baseball and its people. While the chapters are relatively short, they conjure up communal and personal memories. Kurkjian does not dive deeply into any one topic, but he unleashes a flood of information to send any reader down the baseball rabbit hole. He provides an honest account of his time as a baseball journalist and occasional official scorer. 

The final chapter proves Kurkjian is not alone in his baseball obsession. Cal Ripken Jr. spoke at a fundraiser to support Joe Maddon’s hometown, Hazleton, Pennsylvania. Kurkjian moderated the discussion between the two great baseball minds. The stories these baseball lifers could tell are endless. Instead they discussed Ripken calling pitches from Shortstop while Maddon tried to steal his signs. The crowd was transfixed. This is interesting only to those who have been ensnared by baseball and can never untangle themselves. They become obsessed with everything about the only real game. Fortunately for all of us, Tim Kurkjian is afflicted with this obsession and loves to spread the joy of baseball. 

Originally I gave I’m Fascinated by Sacrifice Flies a 7, Triple. However while writing this review my mind continually bounced around the stories within the book. It is a simple book, but by no means insignificant. Kurkjian and his writing stirred my baseball memory and curiosity like few books do. The book earns a well deserved 8, a Home Run.

DJ

The Sixth Lousy Day of Baseball Christmas

On the Sixth Lousy Day of Baseball Christmas the baseball gods sent to me: the most times Caught Stealing without a Stolen Base, the most Hits without an RBI, the most Innings Pitched without a Win or Save, the most Games Managed without finishing first, the most Home Runs without a Triple, and the most Complete Games without a Shutout.

If at first you don’t succeed, try try try again. Failure is part of baseball. Successful batters fail seven out of ten times. Pitchers do not always throw strikes. Umpires miss calls. It is part of the game. When a runner fails on the bases, they can kill a rally. The undisputed Stolen Base king, Rickey Henderson, is also the Caught Stealing king. Success comes with risk. Unfortunately for Oscar Robles, he took the risk without any reward. He was Caught Stealing the most times without a successful Stolen Base, 0 for 8. 

Robles split his time between Shortstop and Third Base in three seasons for the Los Angeles Dodgers (2005-2006) and San Diego Padres (2007). 2005 was his best season, playing 110 Games, hitting .272, collecting 99 Hits, including his 5 career Home Runs, and 8 Stolen Base attempts. 

Oscar Robles tried to help the Dodgers by stealing a base, but was out every time. (Jae C. Hong/AP)

Success comes to those who try and Robles tried. On June 4th against the Milwaukee Brewers, Robles Singled off Victor Santos. The Dodgers tried to hit and run with Antonio Perez, but Perez struckout and Damian Miller threw Robles out at Second. Two weeks later in Chicago against the White Sox, Robles walked in the 2nd Inning. He then tried to steal Second against Freddy Garcia, but A.J. Pierzynski’s arm was faster than Robles’ legs. Out at Second. In the 9th Inning Cliff Politte walked Robles, who tried to steal again. Pierzynski’s throw beat Robles. Tadahito Iguchi caught the ball and ran Robles back to First, tossing the ball to Paul Konerko for the tag. 0 for 2 on the day. 

Robles was not deterred. On July 10th in Houston Brad Ausmus threw Robles out. In his final three Stolen Base attempts his teammates failed to protect him. Robles was part of a Strike Out Throw Out Double Play on July 15th against the Giants with Mike Matheny catching. On August 12th against the Mets, Jeff Kent struckout and Mike Piazza completed the Double Play. Danny Ardoin threw Robles out on August 23rd after Hee-Seop Choi whiffed against Colorado’s Jamey Wright. Oscar Robles’ final attempt was on September 5th against the Giants. Mike Edwards struckout and Yamid Haad threw Robles out. 

Half of Robles’ Caught Stealings were part of Strike Out Throw Out Double Plays. His teammates failed him. Unfortunately, Oscar Robles is saddled with the record for most Stolen Base attempts without success. His futility on the bases demonstrates how difficult baseball is to play. Some players are just dealt bad hands.

Happy Sixth Lousy Day of Baseball Christmas.

DJ

Error of Their Ways

Putting the ball in play puts pressure on the defense. A fielder can drop a fly ball, boot a grounder, or throw the ball away. Even the most routine play is not automatic. However, are all Errors bad? Are they the mark of a poor defender? Could they be a sign of a good defender?

Herman Long holds the record for most career Errors, 1,096. The logical assumption is he was a terrible defender. However, there is a reason he played 16 seasons in the Major Leagues. Long played Shortstop from 1889 to 1904 for the Kansas City Cowboys, Boston Beaneaters, New York Highlanders, Detroit Tigers, and Philadelphia Phillies posting a 16.8 dWAR, 83rd highest all time. In 11,881 Chances, he made 4,450 Putouts with 6,335 Assists, and turned 785 Double Plays. Long had a career .908 Fielding % (Fld%), 5.86 Range Factor per 9 Innings (RF9), and a 5.73 Range Factor per Game (RFG). Range Factor is the number of plays a player is involved in per game or per 9 innings. It is especially useful when comparing players from the same era. Herman Long’s contemporaries at Shortstops posted a .904 Fld%, 5.67 lgRF9, and 5.50 lgRFG. Long was better by .004 Fld%, 0.19 RF9, and 0.23 RFG. These differences are a few plays over a long season, but they can alter a tight pennant race. 

Herman Long received just one Hall of Fame vote, others have entered team hall of fames or Cooperstown due to their skill with the glove. The Human Vacuum, the Wizard, and the Blade are among the best defensive infielders ever. Brooks Robinson spent his entire 23 season career in Baltimore stationed at third base for the Orioles. The Human Vacuum committed 264 Errors, compiled the third highest career dWAR, 39.1, and won 16 Gold Gloves. Robinson was an institution at the hot corner. In 9,196 Chances, he made 2,712 Putouts with 6,220 Assists, and turned 621 Double Plays. He had a career .971 Fld%, 3.20 RF9, 3.08 RFG, and 293 Total Zone Total Fielding (Rtot). Rtot is the number of runs above or below average a player is worth based on the number of plays made. The other third basemen of Robinson’s era had a .953 Fld%, 3.09 lgRF9, and 3.10 lgRFG. Robinson surpassed his contemporaries by .018 Fld% and 0.11 RF9, but had a -0.02 RFG. 

Ozzie Smith is possibly the greatest defensive Shortstop in baseball history. He won 13 Gold Gloves while creating the highest dWAR ever, 44.2. During the Wizard’s 19 season career, he had 12,905 Chances, made 4,249 Putouts with 8,375 Assists, turned 1,590 Double Plays, and committed 281 Errors, 285th most all time. It is easy to assert a player’s greatest, but do the numbers back up your opinion. Smith had a career .978 Fld%, 5.22 RF9, 5.03 RFG, and 239 Rtot. The other Shortstops had a .966 lgFld%, 4.78 lgRF9, and 4.77 lgRFG. Smith outpaced his contemporaries by .022 Fld%, 0.44 RF9, and 0.26 RFG. The Wizard of Oz was more than backflips. If he could not make a play it was probably impossible.

Ozzie Smith flipped the baseball world upside down with his defense. (Post-Dispatch/ Gary Bohn)

Less heralded than Robinson and Smith, Mark Belanger was a defensive master. He won 8 Gold Gloves and his 39.5 dWAR is second behind Ozzie Smith. In 18 seasons, Belanger had 9,082 Chances, made 3,040 Putouts with 5,831 Assists, and turned 1,061 Double Plays, against just 211 Errors. His defensive excellence ranks him outside the top 400 in career Errors. Belanger’s career .977 Fld%, 5.16 RF9, 4.50 RFG, and 241 Rtot far outpaced his competition. Other Shortstops had a .964 Fld%, 4.93 lgRF9, and 4.92 lgRFG. The Blade was better, .013 Fld%, 0.23 RF9, and -0.43 RFG. Belanger’s long and productive career with the glove did not however take him to Cooperstown like Robinson and Smith, receiving 3.7% of the vote in 1988, his only year on the ballot. 

Baseball teams rely on their defense to make routine plays every time and incredible plays whenever possible. Players do occasionally boot routine plays or try to do too much. Baseball history is littered with examples. Currently Starlin Castro and Elvis Andrus are locked in a fight for most Errors among active players. Both have quietly built strong careers, but have taken different paths to this point.

Elvis Andrus arrived in Texas as part of the Mark Teixeira trade with Atlanta. In 12 seasons with the Rangers, Andrus has had 7,210 Chances, made 2,529 Putouts with 4,487 Assists, turned 1,064 Double Plays, and committed 194 Errors. He has a career .973 Fld%, 4.47 RF9, 4.31 RFG, and 52 Rtot. Other Shortstops have a .973 Fld%, 4.17 lgRF9, and 4.14 lgRFG. The Fld% is identical, but Andrus has a higher RF9 and RFG, 0.30 and 0.17 respectively. This greater Range has produced a 10.7 dWAR, 211th all time. Elvis Andrus has helped Texas defensively by creating more Chances and thus more outs.

Elvis Andrus has been an elite defender for the Rangers with his terrific Range at Shortstop. (Richard Rodriguez/ Getty Images)

Starlin Castro broke in with the Chicago Cubs as a 20 year old, playing 123 games his first season. He has played 11 seasons for the Cubs, Yankees, Marlins, and Nationals. Castro has not enjoyed the same defensive success as Elvis Andrus as they approach 200 career Errors. In 6,170 Chances, Castro has 2,197 Putouts with 3,778 Assists, turned 757 Double Plays, and committed 195 Errors. He has career .968 Fld%, 4.22 RF9, 4.05 RFG, and -32 Rtot. Compared to his contemporaries at Short and Second, Castro has not fared well against their .976 Fld%, 4.29 lgRF9, and 4.26 lgRFG. He is behind in all three measurements, -.008 Fld%, -0.07 RF9, and -0.04 RFG. Castro transitioned from Shortstop to Second Base after spending roughly 60% of his career games at Short. The move to Second has hidden some of his lack of range. However, Castro is barely an above defender, posting a 1.2 career dWAR. His first four seasons in the Majors saw him commit 27, 29, 27, and 22 Errors. While Castro has improved, at best he is league average. 

Fielding statistics are not simply counting Errors. Fielding must be compared against other players from the same era. Baseball Reference lists the top 500 single seasons for Errors. Only 14 of the top 500 seasons occurred since 1920, and none since 1941. Resting atop this dubious leaderboard are Herman Long (1889) and Billy Shindle (1890), each committing 122 Errors. 

Starlin Castro is not the best with the glove, but his bat has kept him in the Majors. (Chris Humphreys- US PRESSWIRE)

In 1889, Long set the record with 122 Errors. He had 983 Chances, made 355 Putouts with 506 Assists, and turned 59 Double Plays. Despite his apparent struggles, Long was an above average Shortstop. He had a .874 Fld%, 6.60 RF9, and 6.36 RFG against the league’s .873 Fld%, 5.32 lgRF9, and 5.13 lgRFG. Long had a .001 Fld%, 1.28 RF9, and 1.23 RFG advantage. Long, like Andrus, made plays at a league average rate but created more Chances due to his greater Range. The following season Billy Shindle also committed 122 Errors. He had 834 Chances, made 268 Putouts with 444 Assists while turning 67 Double Plays. Shindle posted a .862 Fld%, 5.62 RF9, and 5.45 RFG, whereas his opponents posted a .868 Fld%, 5.27 lgRF9, and 5.13 lgRFG. Shindle converted Chances into outs below the league average, -.006 Fld%, but he fielded more balls in play, 0.35 RF9 and 0.32 RFG. Creating Chances improves a team’s likelihood of winning by limiting their opponent’s scoring opportunities.

Players can commit Errors on Chances that others watch go by for hits. Simply counting Errors does not provide a complete picture of a player’s defensive abilities. Their Range is equally important to their Fielding %. Players must field a ball before they can convert Chances into outs. Errors can happen from bad bounces or throws, but the real value of a defender is can they create more Chances and outs in support of their pitcher and team. Errors are part of baseball, but they are not entirely bad, there is more than meets the eye.

DJ

Supporting Jackie

Every year baseball remembers Jackie Robinson and his herculean task of breaking baseball’s color barrier. Nothing can sufficiently repay Robinson for the abuse he endured. While he was the focal point of baseball’s integration he was not alone, other trail blazers followed him to integrate every team. Collectively they changed baseball and America forever. They shouldered the weight of integration with some help along the way.

Branch Rickey believed Jackie Robinson could handle the abuse the first African American player would face. Robinson endured abuse from fans and opposing players. Even the Dodger locker room was not a safe haven. When he arrived in Brooklyn several players began a petition stating their desire to be traded rather than play with Robinson. The petition sought to force Branch Rickey to end his attempt to integrate baseball. Several players signed the petition, but it was critical that the de facto team captain sign to show a united front against Robinson. There was little doubt he would sign, having grown up in Louisville, Kentucky, surely a southern man would refuse to play alongside Robinson.

Harold Henry “Pee Wee” Reese was a southern man, but he held no animosity towards anyone based upon their skin color. When approached by his teammates Reese refused to sign, killing the petition. The other Dodgers may not have liked Robinson, but the locker room was now free from the abuse raining down on the field. 

robreese
Pee Wee Reese was a Hall of Fame Shortstop for the Brooklyn Dodgers and friend to Jackie Robinson. (National Baseball Library and Archives, Cooperstown, NY)

Reese was called up to Brooklyn in 1940 and remained with the Dodgers for his entire career, retiring after the Dodgers first season in Los Angeles in 1958. He served in the Navy during World War II, missing three seasons from 1943 to 1945. Upon returning from the Navy, Reese began his career in earnest. His greatest season was 1949. In 155 Games, Reese led the National League with 132 Runs scored, collected 172 Hits including 27 Doubles, 3 Triples, and 16 Home Runs. He had 73 RBI and stole 26 Bases. Reese walked 116 times with just 59 Strikeouts. He hit .279, with an .396 OBP, .410 SLG, .806 OPS, and an 113 OPS+. Reese was named team captain before the following season. 

Reese played 2,166 Games. He scored 1,338 Runs, collected 2,170 Hits including 330 Doubles, 80 Triples, and 126 Home Runs with 885 RBI. He stole 232 Bases, drew 1,210 Walks with 890 Strikeouts. He hit .269, with an .366 OBP, .377 SLG, .743 OPS, and an 99 OPS+. Shortstops were supposed to focus their attention on defense, but Reese was an elite offensive Shortstop. 

Reese played more than 2,000 games at Shortstop. He led National League Shortstops in Putouts in four seasons. Over 60 years after his retirement, Reese still has the 12th most Putous and 13th most Double Plays for Shortstops. He was a solid defender even using modern metrics having led all National League players in dWAR in 1942, 1947, 1948, and 1949. His 25.6 career dWAR is the 17th highest of all time, regardless of position. 

Pee Wee Reese was selected to 10 All Star Games and finished in the top 10 for MVP voting eight times. He led the Dodgers to seven World Series, all against the Yankees. Reese has the most World Series appearances with one team for a non-Yankee. Despite their success the Dodgers won only one World Series. Brooklyn lost in 1941, 1947, 1949, 1952, 1953, and 1956. Reese and Elston Howard have the most World Series defeats, six. Brooklyn won their lone World Series in 1955. Failure was not Reese’s fault. In 44 World Series Games, he scored 20 Runs, collected 46 Hits including 4 Doubles, 2 Triples, and 2 Home Runs with 16 RBI. He Stole 5 Bases, drew 18 Walks with 17 Strikeouts. He hit .272, with an .346 OBP, .349 SLG, and an .695 OPS. 

In 1984, the Veteran’s Committee selected Reese for induction into the Baseball Hall of Fame. The committee referenced his play and support of Jackie Robinson in their reasoning for his selection. No moment better underscores the support Reese gave Robinson than at Crosley Field in Cincinnati in 1947. Amid a deluge of abuse Reese put his arm around Robinson. The show of support told the crowd and opposing players that Reese supported his teammate and would defend his friend against the abuse. Some claim the event occurred in Boston against the Braves at Braves Field in 1948. Regardless where and when it occurred Reese helped ease the chaos surrounding baseball’s integration.

Robinson-Reese-Statue
Pee Wee Reese showing his support for Jackie Robinson was critical in helping Robinson and other African American players successfully integrate baseball. (Ron Cervenka)

Reese standing with his arm around Robinson is immortalized in bronze and granite outside MCU Park, home of the Brooklyn Cyclones. Reese could not deflect all the abuse directed at Robinson, but he could support him in public and private. A white player standing with Jackie Robinson was critical. The support coming from a southern man was monumental. Reese did not care what color Robinson was, they were teammates. Reese was asked if he was worried about losing his job prior to Robinson joining the Dodgers, If he’s man enough to take my job, I’m not gonna like it, but, dammit, black or white, he deserves it. Instead of replacing him, Robinson and Reese formed a dynamic Double Play combination. Reese joked with Robinson to ease some of the tension, he cared about Robinson the man beyond baseball. Their friendship lasted a lifetime, as Reese was a pallbearer at Jackie Robinson’s funeral. 

People are rarely successful on their own, they receive support along the way. Jackie Robinson faced unfathomable abuse as he integrated baseball. No one could shield him from the onslaught. However, people like Pee Wee Reese helped lighten the burden. On this Jackie Robinson Day let us remember Robinson’s great courage and sacrifice to improve baseball and America. Let us also not forget those who helped him achieve success, including his teammate and friend Pee Wee Reese. Small gestures can change history.

DJ

The Best of the Best?

All Star voting is over and the starters for the Mid-Summer Classic are set. On July 9th, Cleveland hosts the 90th MLB All Star Game with the best players taking the field, in theory. Baseball altered the election process this year for All Star starters. It is an important step towards ensuring the best players are All Stars each season.

MLB continues the mass voting fans are accustomed to, giving every player the opportunity to be elected. This year however the top three vote getters at each position faced a runoff for the right to start the All Star Game. This extra layer of voting helps guard against a pure popularity contest, forcing voters to reexamine players a second time. While it is not a perfect system, it is a step in the right direction. Players still need fan support, but the second round of voting helps prevent players like Aaron Judge from starting the All Star Game with just 32 games played for the Yankees this season. Judge is talented, but he is not an All Star this season; he finished fourth, just missing an undeserved All Star Game. Houston’s Carlos Correa finished third among American League Shortstops. He has placed 50 games this season, more than Judge, but not enough to earn the honor of starting the All Star Game. MLB ought to establish a minimum games played threshold for All Star voting eligibility. 

Judge and Correa should play in many future All Star Games, just not this season. If the idea of the All Star Game is to have the best players on the field, some high priced talent will miss out. Manny Machado and Bryce Harper were not voted into the All Star Game by the fans. Big free agent contracts do not guarantee All Star Games. The fans elect who they want to play, but even this idea has been an issue in the past. 

Tommy Pham
Tommy Pham raised a good point that All Star voting is unfair. MLB changed the voting process this season, but more may need to be done. (www.calltothepen.com)

Before the Big Red Machine began dominating baseball, it was the Cincinnati fans causing havoc. In 1957, Cincinnati fans so over stuffed the ballot box that seven Reds were elected to the All Star Game in St. Louis. Stan Musial was the only non-Reds starter. The farce forced Commissioner Ford Frick to step in, replacing two Reds players, Wally Post and Gus Bell, with Willie Mays and Hank Aaron. Frick went further, revoking the fan All Star vote until 1970. 

Ballot stuffing continued in the computer age. In 1999 a computer programmer electronically stuffed the ballot for Boston’s Nomar Garciaparra. When discovered, Garciaparra lost 25,259 ill gotten votes, though he still started the All Star Game at Fenway Park over Derek Jeter

The 2015 Kansas City Royals brought back memories of the 1957 Reds. Leading up to the All Star Game, fittingly played in Cincinnati. Eight Royals led at their respective positions. There was not a repeat of 1957, as Kansas City ultimately had four All Star starters. A single team having a stranglehold on the All Star Game may not be in the best interest of baseball, even if they win the World Series like the Royals in 2015.

The Mid-Summer Classic returns to Cleveland for the first time since 1997 and to an American League ballpark for the first time since Minnesota hosted in 2014. The All Star Game is an exhibition. Yes the winning league gets home field advantage in the World Series, but this only impacts two teams. I doubt the Orioles and Marlins representatives will fight with extra vigor to secure home field advantage should their team have a miraculous second half turn around. The All Star Game is about seeing the best in the game play together one night a year. Interleague play has somewhat diluted the intrigue of the All Star Game. National League fans can see Mike Trout and American League fans can see Nolan Arenado more than one night a year. Despite the waning of the All Star Game’s novelty, the game is still important for growing the game and the enjoyment of the fans. 

MLB is right to tweak the All Star Game voting process. It will never be perfect. Some deserving players are snubbed each year, but this is better than a return to fans are having no vote. Baseball must keep the fans involved, but there are limits.  A small portion of fans in the past ruined the fun of voting. MLB should continue to tweak the process from year to year. There will never be a perfect All Star Game, but the change to two rounds of voting is a good first step.  

DJ